Close Menu
    World Cup 2026

    DEBATE: Is Rashford BETTER Than Saka & Foden?



    EXCLUSIVE NordVPN Deal ➼ https://nordvpn.com/theclub
    Try it risk-free now with a 30-day money-back guarantee!

    @RoryJenningsFootball, @AdamMcKola & @Buvey debate who they should start, sell and bench out of Marcus Rashford, Bukayo Saka & Phil Foden.

    Listen to the FULL PODCAST here: https://open.spotify.com/show/2tLV2wP8g8mDMh6F7YdI2B?utm_medium=share&utm_source=linktree

    Join The Club
    Linktree – https://linktr.ee/theclublive
    TikTok – https://www.tiktok.com/@theclublivetiktok
    Twitter – https://twitter.com/TheClubLiveTw
    Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/theclubliveinsta/

    Follow the lads on social 📱

    Adam McKola
    YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@AdamMcKola
    Twitter – https://twitter.com/AdamMcKola
    Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/adammckola/
    TikTok – https://www.tiktok.com/@adammckola_

    Rory Jennings
    YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@RoryJenningsFootball
    Twitter – https://twitter.com/Chelsearory
    Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/chelsearory/
    TikTok – https://www.tiktok.com/@chelsearory

    Buvey
    YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@Buvey
    Twitter – https://twitter.com/lawrence_bury
    Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/buvey_/
    TikTok – https://www.tiktok.com/@buvey_

    View 50 Comments

    50 Comments

    5. Isaac Hilton on

      Honestly, I never comment and I don't care if no one sees this. The disrespect on Rashford is mad. If this cunt was playing for either one of their clubs they'd adore him (just like Mason Mount who is no where as he should be if you can understand football Rory). Everyone is still out with the Man It'd agenda because of how much it traumatized you as a kid (or 30 year old Rory). The worst part is you'll find some stupid way to argue this if you see it but you know I'm right and I'm pissed rn, so go ahead.

    8. Mike More on

      Foden is one of the most overrated players ever. He pops up with a cameo goal every 7 weeks, and everyone loses their mind, while Rashford and Saka are carrying water for their teams week in, week out.

    10. b moseley on

      I understand why there not on the kick off but why do they rip it to pieces all the time is it bad blood or Purley just for the awful comments

    13. Stanley Wilder on

      rashfords got almost triple the amount of goals and nearly double the goal contributions as saka this season. Stats aren't everything but at the same time you can't ignore how impressive rashfords goalscoring ability has been. Considering they're both wide players too you cannot tell me that saka has had a better individual season than rashford. As for foden, there is no way he's been anywhere near the other two this season with pep seeming to be favouring Grealish more.

    14. Stanley Wilder on

      Overall I'd say Rashford is the best player, followed by Foden and then saka. This season Foden has performed the worst of the 3. The way I see it, Rashford takes top spot coz he has proved his ability properly by having multiple high scoring and assisting seasons, playing for a generally poor utd team since his debut and he's also scored many goals against big opponents. I believe saka can get very close in a couple seasons numbers wise and maybe even has a higher ceiling than rashford but right now its clear who's the better player.

    15. E2J - Music on

      The reality is this. You can’t compare the 3. Saka is 21, whilst Rashford is 26 this year. Foden doesn’t get enough minutes at City too. Rashford features as a striker for at least 35% of games per season… and Foden features at the 9 sometimes too. Foden has an elite team around him that enables him to have space on the field. Saka is a right winger in a system that’s suited to his attributes. The reality is, stats don’t mean anything… consistency does. Saka is the most consistent, Rashford 2nd and Foden 3rd.

    23. Adam419 on

      Geezer in the black hoodie needs to wined his neck in the clown😂 needs his jaw clipped, pulling faces like that in a talk about football players hahaha rashy all day but👀

    25. Cal Smith on

      Start Rashford
      Bench Saka
      Sell Foden

      Rashford is currently top 5 players in the world
      Saka is a baller
      Foden is a system player

    27. Clint Eastwood on

      From a city fan, start Marcus, bench foden (only due to potential) compared to Saka. Yes he’s having a better season but on form Foden is a baller

    30. Kishan K on

      Foden has a goal contribution every 108 mins this season.
      Rashford has a goal contribution every 125 mins this season.
      And supposedly rashford is having the best season of his career.
      Foden is clear

    31. nits on

      I completely agree with Buvey. As a Man City fan his club has been caught cheating FFP, so in his mind all he is thinking is, who do I sell to get most money out of the 3, and the answer is simple.

    38. kai lunt on

      Foden is comfortably the worse atm. He hasn't improved since he first joined and never had a season better than saka or rashford playing for the most dominant team in the Premier league

    42. Ronan Thomas on

      On form at the minute, start Rashford, Bench Saka, Sell Foden. Rashfords currently one of the top players in the world, Saka has had like 1 and a half good seasons so far, could be better than Rashford down the line, Foden l wouldn't say is particularly tearing it up at City. Pretty sure if City put any of their players in Fodens position they do just as well.

    47. David Bowen on

      Saka is a more well rounded player. Rashford can be dynamic but Saka is more likely to pick the right option and help his team maintain its cohesion. Hes younger and is on a comparable level. He still shows up in big moment regardless of his age.

    48. sipho banda on

      Icl foden is the most overrated player in the prem ….apparently bro is good at all these things but we never see him do the week in week out

    Leave A Reply