There are only 2 that can be the best, and it depends on the definition you want to use as best, either Franz or Gerd, Franz was the best IMO, he defined a position in football, Gerd is the player with the biggest Bayern legacy, no one has brought more to the club on the field than him.
Gichtschwein on
Thomas Müller 🙂 – because he is one of a kind.
Der_Betrachter on
Kaiser
alexunknown91 on
Mané wasn’t overrated at all, he was just brought in with the expectations that he could do something he has never done successfully before in his career play as a ST/False 9
easyGame23 on
Franz Beckenbauer
flauxpas on
Robben or Scholl
Late_Ruin_6040 on
Benckenbauer
happylakers on
Beckenbauer for sure, everything else is wrong. Sorry to say
Pherryl on
Ganz im Ernst. Ich finde wenn man schon den besten Spieler jemals auf der Position hatte sollte man ihn auch nehmen. Manuel Neuer.
GF_D_presents3456 on
Probably Beckenbauer it’s a given
DiscipleofDrax on
Beckenbauer for greatest club player ever, Manuel Neuer for best club player ever IMO.
PenaltyFull on
Manuel Neuer – revolutionized the keeper position
New_Membership_2937 on
So many greats. I am gonna throw in Loddar! Matthäus was special. Yes Der Kaiser likely takes this but the career Matthäus had is special. Also special shout out to Kalle Rummenigge since he was my favorite player when I was 4 and is the reason I have been a Bayern fan now for nearly 50 years.
Honigbrottr on
Bin hin und her gerissen zwischen Beckenbauer und Müller. T Müller hat halt einfach eine Position die halt danach auch keiner ausfüllt. Man merkts wenn der Müller nicht aufn Platz ist, wenn er aufn platz ist merkt man aber gar nicht wie viel der eigentlich bringt.
Beckenbauer war aber halt einfach der beste. Kann mich nicht entscheiden
LongjumpingTop1450 on
Neuer #1
Admiral-SJ on
Franz Beckenbauer
Steveo7980 on
For me it has to be Thomas Muller but I’d accept Gerd Muller a close second
JMarduk on
Lahm is the best that has ever been in his position.
Doggyd717 on
Either the Kaiser or Gerd
GeorgeOrwells1985 on
Weird definition of overrated. Mane was just over the hill. He was a class player at his best
26 Comments
Gerd Müller
Robert Lewandowski
Beckenbauer
Rummenigge
Der Kaiser Beckenbauer
There are only 2 that can be the best, and it depends on the definition you want to use as best, either Franz or Gerd, Franz was the best IMO, he defined a position in football, Gerd is the player with the biggest Bayern legacy, no one has brought more to the club on the field than him.
Thomas Müller 🙂 – because he is one of a kind.
Kaiser
Mané wasn’t overrated at all, he was just brought in with the expectations that he could do something he has never done successfully before in his career play as a ST/False 9
Franz Beckenbauer
Robben or Scholl
Benckenbauer
Beckenbauer for sure, everything else is wrong. Sorry to say
Ganz im Ernst. Ich finde wenn man schon den besten Spieler jemals auf der Position hatte sollte man ihn auch nehmen. Manuel Neuer.
Probably Beckenbauer it’s a given
Beckenbauer for greatest club player ever, Manuel Neuer for best club player ever IMO.
Manuel Neuer – revolutionized the keeper position
So many greats. I am gonna throw in Loddar! Matthäus was special. Yes Der Kaiser likely takes this but the career Matthäus had is special. Also special shout out to Kalle Rummenigge since he was my favorite player when I was 4 and is the reason I have been a Bayern fan now for nearly 50 years.
Bin hin und her gerissen zwischen Beckenbauer und Müller. T Müller hat halt einfach eine Position die halt danach auch keiner ausfüllt. Man merkts wenn der Müller nicht aufn Platz ist, wenn er aufn platz ist merkt man aber gar nicht wie viel der eigentlich bringt.
Beckenbauer war aber halt einfach der beste. Kann mich nicht entscheiden
Neuer #1
Franz Beckenbauer
For me it has to be Thomas Muller but I’d accept Gerd Muller a close second
Lahm is the best that has ever been in his position.
Either the Kaiser or Gerd
Weird definition of overrated. Mane was just over the hill. He was a class player at his best
Beckenbauer